Trustpilot                         
Google reviews

Article Summary:

  • ‘Special reasons’ are considerations that the court may take into account to discount mandatory penalties for certain motoring offences in England and Wales
  • A special reason for a motoring law offence is not the same as a defence
  • Special reasons must relate to the circumstances of the offence, not the personal circumstances of the offender
  • Typical examples include spiked drinks, genuine emergencies, and genuine nest insurance mistakes.
  • Succeeding with a special reasons argument requires strong evidence and expert legal advice.
Motoring offences in England and Wales often carry mandatory penalties under the law. For example, conviction for drink driving under section 5(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 normally results in a driving disqualification, regardless of intention or the motorist’s personal circumstances. However, the law recognises that some cases deserve special consideration because of the unique facts surrounding the offence; these are ‘special reasons’. In this article, we will explain what is meant by ‘special reasons’ in the context of motoring law offences and how and when the courts consider them to depart from the standard sentence, in rare but justified circumstances.

What is a ‘special reason’ in law in motoring law?

A ‘special reason’ is a legal justification that, if accepted by a judge, can reduce or prevent a mandatory sentence from being handed down. It is important to understand that a ‘special reason’ is not a defence to the charge. To use a special reason, the defendant must have either pleaded guilty or been found guilty of the offence. Section 34(1) of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 gives the courts discretion to consider and apply special reasons; it states “Where a person is convicted of an offence involving obligatory disqualification, the court must order him to be disqualified for such period not less than twelve months as the court thinks fit unless the court, for special reasons, thinks fit to order him to be disqualified for a shorter period or not to order him to be disqualified”. The concept of ‘special reasons’ is not contained in statute but rather in UK case law. Whittall v Kirby  2 All ER 552 and R v Wickens (1958) set out that for a ‘special reason’ to be considered by a judge; it must:
  • Be a mitigating or extenuating circumstance
  • Not amount to a defence to the charge
  • Be directly connected with the commission of the offence itself
  • Be one which ought properly to be taken into consideration when sentencing.
These criteria clarify that ‘special reasons’ focus on the facts and context of the offence, not the knock-on effects on the offender, such as loss of job or family hardship.

What constitutes a ‘special reason’?

There is no definitive list of special reasons for motoring offences, but some that courts have considered in the past include the following:
  • A drink being spiked, which leads a driver to be over the limit. In this scenario, the court may exercise discretion if evidence (medical or eyewitness) shows the offence occurred without intent or knowledge
  • Driving only for a very short distance and in safe conditions (e.g., moving the car within a private car park) may be accepted by the court as a special reason
  • If someone drives in a real emergency, for example, transporting a person to the hospital when no other help was available, or escaping immediate danger, the court may accept this as a mitigating circumstance, provided all other options had been exhausted and the urgency is clear
  • Driving without insurance due to an employer’s lapse may be considered a special reason if the driver took reasonable steps to be insured.
It should be noted at this point that even if you believe that a special reason should be taken into account when considering your sentence or penalty, there is no guarantee that it will be effective. The courts have ultimate discretion and will want to see robust evidence that you have a genuine special reason.

Evidence and burden of proof

If you are facing a charge of a serious motoring offence, it is for you as the defendant to prove that there were special reasons for the motoring offence. The legal test in this situation is on a ‘balance of probabilities’; in other words, the court must be satisfied that it is more likely than not that the special reason is made out. This is the lower civil threshold and is typically easier to meet than the criminal threshold of ‘beyond all reasonable doubt’. Testimony, expert reports (such as toxicology in drink driving cases), and corroborating statements all are vital. The prosecution is allowed to challenge any such evidence. Special reason hearings are separate from the plea hearing and usually follow after a conviction or a guilty plea. Legal submissions and cross-examination of evidence form an important part of proceedings. The process usually proceeds as follows:
  • If a driver pleads guilty (or is found guilty after trial), the court normally moves to sentencing
  • If the driver argues that ‘special reasons’ apply, the court will usually adjourn for a special reasons hearing
  • At the special reasons hearing, evidence is presented (often with witnesses) and the magistrates decide whether the circumstances are sufficient to avoid or reduce mandatory penalties such as disqualification or penalty points.

What is not considered a ‘special reason’?

The following are not normally taken into account as a special reason for a motoring law offence:
  • Personal hardship, such as the risk of losing employment or family difficulties due to the ban.
  • Negligence, such as forgetting to renew insurance or underestimating alcohol absorption time.
  • Minor nature of the offence itself (if it still constitutes an offence under the law).
  • Medical conditions that simply result in excess alcohol in the system (unless it is proven that it did not arise from voluntary drinking).

Special reasons vs mitigation

Mitigating circumstances such as a clean driving record, remorse for the offence, or an early guilty plea may reduce the severity of a penalty, but cannot override the statutory minimum penalty. Special reasons can, if accepted, result in complete avoidance of those penalties, such as no endorsement or disqualification at all. Courts take a cautious and fact-specific approach, requiring thorough evidence and often expert legal representation. Past cases guide (but do not bind) court decisions, meaning that each case is assessed on its own merits. Even if the argument succeeds, conviction still stands on record; only the penalty may be reduced or avoided.

Final Words

The concept of ‘special reasons’ provides an important safeguard in English and Welsh motoring law, allowing courts to exercise discretion and avoid injustices that might arise where the circumstances of an offence truly warrant leniency. However, success depends on convincing evidence and legal submissions. Anyone facing prosecution for a motoring offence should always seek the expertise of a motoring law Solicitor who can advise whether special reasons may genuinely apply in their case.

FAQs

Does successfully arguing ‘special reasons’ mean my conviction is removed?

No, your conviction will remain on record. The court can avoid or reduce the penalty, but you are still found guilty of the offence.

Can loss of employment or family hardship be a ‘special reason’?

No, hardship to the offender or dependents is not a special reason; it must relate to the offence itself.

How does the court decide if a ‘special reason’ exists?

Courts use evidence, witness statements, and legal argument, and are satisfied on the ‘balance of probabilities’. Evidence must link the special reason directly to the offence.

Are ‘special reasons’ accepted for all motoring offences?

Special reasons typically apply to mandatory disqualification or endorsement offences (e.g., drink driving, no insurance); however, courts may still exercise discretion wherever the law allows (s34 Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988).

Should I seek legal advice before arguing special reasons?

Presenting a special reasons argument to the courts can be complex and time-consuming. Expert legal help significantly increases your chance of success.
Related Tags:
Social Share:

Leave a comment